A student who can recite every pathway and freezes on an unfamiliar case has not learned badly. They have learned the content without learning how to use it, and Justin Coffeen says the same gap shows up in research staff.
What this episode covers
- The difference between retrievable knowledge and applicable understanding
- Why teaching and treating patients at the same time exposed the gap in both directions
- Case-based learning as deliberate friction rather than a softer format
- Why understanding the reasoning makes a professional adaptable and memorising the rule makes them fragile
Why do you think that
Justin Coffeen covered anatomy, physiology, histology, and pathology as an instructor at Life Chiropractic College West between 2013 and 2016, while running a practice focused on sports injury management and rehabilitation.
The question he returned to with students was not what the answer is. It was why they thought so. A student who can articulate the reasoning will reach the answer, and a student who cannot has produced a guess that happened to land.
That test transfers cleanly to research work. A coordinator who knows a visit window is seven days has memorised a rule. A coordinator who knows what the window protects can tell the difference between a scheduling inconvenience and a problem worth escalating.
Framework first, specifics second
Onboarding into an unfamiliar therapeutic area is where this matters most. Coffeen does not attempt to absorb a new disease area all at once. He starts with the structure: what the condition is, what the trial is trying to measure, why those endpoints were chosen, and what the population actually experiences day to day.
The detail then has somewhere to attach. Coming at it the other way round produces a coordinator who can recite the schedule of assessments and cannot say what any of it is for.
Justin Coffeen still uses the same question when he trains research staff. Not whether someone knows the rule, but whether they can say out loud what the rule is protecting.
Transcript
Here’s something that happened constantly when I was teaching anatomy and physiology at the graduate level. A student would come in having memorized everything, genuinely, they could recite pathways, name structures, define processes. And then you’d put a real case in front of them, something slightly off the standard presentation, and they’d freeze.
Not because they didn’t know the material. Because they’d learned the material and not learned how to use the material. And I want to be honest: that gap is partly on how we teach.
I was teaching while I was also seeing patients in my chiropractic practice. Sports injuries, rehabilitation, chronic pain work. And what happened is, I’d be in the clinic with a patient and think, I explained this exact mechanism yesterday in class, but the way I explained it in the classroom doesn’t quite match what I’m looking at right now. That friction, between the textbook version and the clinical reality, was the most useful thing I could bring back to the classroom.
What case-based learning does, when it’s done right, is create that friction on purpose. You put the student in a situation where they have to work through uncertainty, where the answer isn’t labeled, where they have to articulate their reasoning rather than recognize a pattern they memorized. And the discomfort of that, I mean students don’t love it, is actually the learning.
The question I asked students constantly was not "what’s the answer" but "why do you think that." Because if they could explain the reasoning, the answer would follow. If they couldn’t, the answer was just a guess that happened to be right this time.
I think about this now in the context of clinical research. When I’m onboarding into a new therapeutic area, I don’t try to absorb everything at once. I try to understand the framework: what is this disease, what is the trial trying to measure, why are these endpoints the right ones, what does the patient population actually experience. The specifics follow from understanding the structure.
Teaching taught me that. Understanding the "why" makes you adaptable. Memorizing the "what" makes you fragile.