Justin Coffeen on Why the Best Clinician Is Not Automatically the Leader

The most technically skilled person in the room is not automatically the leader. Justin Coffeen has worked in four environments that all made that assumption, and watched what it costs.

What this episode covers

  • Why clinical expertise and leadership capacity are different skills, not the same skill at different levels
  • Leadership as the work of holding a team on the right thing when conditions make that hard
  • The coordination problem across investigators, coordinators, sponsors, monitors, IRBs, and participants
  • What communication infrastructure looks like when it exists and when it does not

The promotion that changes the job

A capable clinician gets moved into a role that coordinates other people, and discovers the new work has very little overlap with the work that earned the promotion. The clinical knowledge still matters. It is simply not what the new job is made of.

Justin Coffeen has practised chiropractic medicine, taught at graduate level, served in a medical unit, and worked in clinical research across orthopedics, oncology, and hepatology. His read is that technical competence is the entry requirement rather than the qualification.

Information that stalls is the failure mode

A research site runs on information moving between parties who each hold a different piece. When that movement is reliable the study runs. When it is not, individually small problems accumulate into something nobody can trace.

Coffeen’s practical test is whether every person on a team can answer three questions without hesitating: who to contact when something goes wrong, whether information is flowing in real time or collecting in silos, and whether problems get surfaced early or managed quietly until they cannot be.

None of that is a personality trait. It is infrastructure, and infrastructure is built deliberately or not at all.

Justin Coffeen’s summary is that technical expertise gets a person into the room. What happens to the team once they are in it is a separate skill, and one that almost nobody was formally taught.

Transcript

I want to push back on something I see a lot in healthcare and research: the assumption that the most technically skilled person in the room is naturally the leader, or should be. That clinical expertise and leadership capacity are basically the same thing at different levels.

They’re not. I say that as someone who has practiced chiropractic medicine, taught at the graduate level, served in a military medical unit, and worked in clinical research across orthopedics, oncology, and hepatology. These environments all require technical competence. None of them were led well simply because the person at the front was the most technically skilled.

Here’s what I think leadership actually is, at least in these environments: it’s the ongoing work of keeping a team focused on the right thing when the environment is making it hard to stay focused. And the right thing changes depending on what you’re doing. In a clinical practice, it’s the patient in front of you. In a research setting, it’s participant safety and data integrity. In the military, the mission is explicit enough that you don’t have to debate it.

The coordination piece is what I think about most. In clinical research, you’ve got investigators, coordinators, sponsors, monitors, IRBs, and participants, all nominally working toward the same goal. Whether they actually function as a team depends entirely on the communication infrastructure. Does everyone know who to contact when something goes wrong? Is information flowing in real time or accumulating in silos? Are problems surfaced early or managed quietly until they can’t be managed anymore?

I’ve seen what happens when that infrastructure doesn’t exist. And I’ve seen, in the Air Force especially, what it looks like when it does. The difference in how teams perform under pressure is significant.

I’m based in Lakewood Ranch, Florida, and the thread through all of my professional environments has been this: technical expertise gets you in the room. What you do with the team once you’re there, that’s the leadership question.